Kitchens and bathrooms are among the most frequently used spaces in any home, and the cabinets within them bear the brunt of daily activities. Over time, the wear and tear can take its toll, leaving you with cabinets that look a little worse for wear. This makes us ask: When should you fix or give your broken cabinets a new look? Understanding the difference can help you save time and money while keeping your rooms looking good.

Assessing the Damage

Before making any decisions, a thorough assessment of your cabinets is necessary. It’s crucial to look beyond the surface level and check for structural issues. If the integrity of the cabinetry is compromised, repairs might be more extensive than you’d initially think. Check for issues such as:

  • Warped or bent frames

  • Loose or broken hinges

  • Drawer slides that no longer function smoothly

  • Signs of water damage like swelling or discoloration

  • Cracks in the wood or peeling veneer

Minor issues such as scratches, dents, or worn-out paint point towards a simpler solution like refacing, while more significant problems require repairs or even a full replacement.

When to Mend the Broken

Minor Cosmetic Issues: Minor cosmetic damage can often be repaired with a bit of elbow grease and the right materials. For instance, scratches can be filled in, and new paint or finish can be applied to give cabinets a fresh appearance.

Functionality Fix: Sometimes, it’s a matter of fixing a broken hinge or replacing a faulty drawer slide. These repairs are usually straightforward and do not require a complete overhaul of your cabinets.

Preserving Character: In cases where you have custom or antique cabinetry that adds character to your home, repair is often the preferred route. It allows you to maintain the original aesthetic while restoring functionality.

A Fresh New Look Without the Hassle

When your cabinets are structurally sound but look tired on the outside, refacing is a fantastic option. This process involves replacing the cabinet doors, drawer fronts, and hardware and applying new veneer to the existing frame. Here’s when refacing might be the best course of action:

Modernizing Your Space: If your goal is to update the look of your kitchen or bathroom without a complete remodel, refacing offers an efficient solution to change styles, colors, and finishes.

Cost-Effective Renovations: Refacing is generally less expensive than buying brand-new cabinets and involves less disruption to your daily life during the process.

Sustainability: Choosing to reface rather than replace is an eco-friendly option, as it reduces the waste sent to the landfill.

Refacing can also be considered when looking to update key areas like a bathroom vanity. A stylish vanity can transform the feel of a bathroom, and refacing gives you the opportunity to experiment with new materials and designs without the need for a complete replacement.

Repair vs. Reface

To make the best decision, weigh the cost of repair versus refacing. If repairs are extensive, then refacing—or possibly full replacement—might make more financial sense. Consider the following factors when making your decision:

  • Cost: What option fits within your budget?

  • Longevity: Will repairs extend the life of your cabinets sufficiently, or is refacing a better investment?

  • Value: Are you looking to increase your home’s resale value? Refacing might have a bigger impact.

  • Time: How quickly do you need the job done?

The Role of Home Remodeling

When tackling a home remodeling project, it’s important to consider every detail, including the style and functionality of your cabinets. If you’re addressing a larger home transformation, you might find it beneficial to explore various design options and resources. For instance, a professional remodeling company can offer insights into the latest trends and materials. By visiting their website, you can access photo galleries, design tips, and interactive tools to help visualize your remodeled space. 

Cost Considerations

It’s important to consider the costs associated with both repairing and refacing carefully. High-quality repairs may require professional labor and, depending on the extent of the damage, can be quite costly. Meanwhile, refacing offers a semi-custom look at a lower cost than full cabinet replacement. To determine the best financial route, request quotes for both options and compare them against the overall benefits.

Durability and Lifespan

Consider the lifespan of the repair or refacing job. Quality repairs can last a long time if the damage is not structural. As for refacing, the new materials applied to the cabinet exteriors will also have their longevity, depending on the quality of the materials and installation work.

Determining Your Home’s Needs

Every home is unique, and thus, the decision to repair or reface cabinets should be tailored to your specific needs. If functionality is the issue, lean towards repair. If it’s purely aesthetic or you’re seeking to upgrade the look of your cabinets as part of a larger remodeling project, refacing could be the more suitable choice.

DIY vs. Professional Refacing

Pros of DIY Refacing

Cost Effectiveness

  • Significantly reduces costs by eliminating professional labor fees.

  • Allows for budget flexibility – you can choose less expensive materials.

Personal Satisfaction

  • Provides a sense of accomplishment from completing the project yourself.

  • Offers the ability to fully customize the project to your taste.

Flexible Timeline

  • You can work at your own pace and on your own schedule.

  • Ability to pause and restart the project as needed without depending on a contractor’s timetable.


Cons of DIY Refacing

Skill Level

  • Requires a certain level of handiness and familiarity with tools.

  • Mistakes can be costly and difficult to fix without professional help.

Time Investment

  • Time-consuming project, especially if you’re learning as you go.

  • Can be disruptive to daily life, with kitchen facilities unavailable for extended periods.

Quality of Finish

  • Results may lack the professional touch, potentially affecting the aesthetic and resale value of your home.

  • Longevity of the refacing might be compromised without professional techniques and materials.

Tools and Equipment

  • Need to purchase or rent the necessary tools, which can offset some

The Environmental Factor

Another consideration is the environmental impact of your decision. Repairing and reusing cabinets are more sustainable options than discarding and replacing them. If environmental concerns are important to you, leaning toward repairs or refacing is a responsible choice.

Final Thoughts

The decision to repair or reface your cabinets hinges on several factors, including the extent of damage, cost, time constraints, aesthetic goals, and environmental considerations. Taking the time to assess your cabinets and understanding your goals for your space can guide you to the right choice for your home. Whether it’s a simple touch-up, a stylish reface, or a more complex repair, your cabinets can be brought back to life, contributing to the beauty and functionality of your home.


Back To Top